Tuesday, April 09, 2013

Intellectual property rights vs Profit protection right ??

Knowledge@Wharton : Patent Controversy Resumes as Indian Supreme Court Rejects Novartis’ Glivec Claim


This is not at all an 'intellectual property rights' vs 'affordability' case as its being painted all over but really a simpler case on extension of patent beyond its original period. The drug in question was awarded patent long back for its innovation at that time and Novartis has reaped all the benefits of exclusivity awarded by the patent regime - even in India.

Now, when the patent is about to expire, the company management in order to retain its large pharma status (and of course profits) make inconsequential changes to the manufacturing process (to simplify: say replace cane sugar in lemonade with equivalent amount of corn sugar) and call it a new innovation and demand patent over it. The so called innovation does not impact the efficacy of the drug and is just a physical modification made only to "evergreen" the patent. The driver of such practice is not at all any innovation but is really monopolistic practices to make huge profits.

Unfortunately, most countries like USA does not recognize this ever-greening as a monopolistic malpractice and its only Indian patent law which disallows such practice. Indian courts just upheld the law of the land to reject the patent application of Novartis which did not brought any real innovation.

Even more unfortunate is that globally India is maligned now to be stealing intellectual property. The lobby groups of big pharma (who thrive on a fraction of profits made by companies through such monopolistic practices) are going hitter titter calling names to India and its courts. Some groups are supporting the cause for the benefits it serve to poor around the world by generally reducing the cost of such drugs by ~95%-97% (imagine the profit margin of big pharma). But benefit to poor is only a consequence of the law and its not any robin hood philosophy behind it.

The intellectuals of the world should debate if the intellectual property rights are really about protecting ingenuity or profits ?

10 comments:

Ashish Gupta said...

Rasta bhool gaye blog ka?

But rightly said.

Unknown said...

Hey, very nice site. I came across this on Google, and I am stoked that I did. I will definitely be coming back here more often. Wish I could add to the conversation and bring a bit more to the table, but am just taking in as much info as I can at the moment. Thanks for sharing.
Side Wheel Attachment Dealer

Keep Posting:)

jalpa prajapati said...

Thanks for such very great information. This is the best sites for proving such kinds of good information.Examhelpline.in

jalpa prajapati said...

such a really amazing information... thank you given to us..
CUSAT CAT Application Form 2017
AP ICET Application Form 2017
HBSE 12th Result 2017
MP SET Admit CArd 2017
careinfo.in
carebaba.com

jalpa prajapati said...

such a wonderful post sharing with us...thanks.
HBSE 10th result 2017
HPBOSE 10th result 2017
ICSE 10th result 2017
JAC 10th result 2017
JKBOSE 10th Board Result 2017
Karnataka SSLC Result 2017

jalpa prajapati said...

amazing post thanks a lot sharing with us.
JIPMER MBBS Admit card 2017
UP Urdu Teacher Merit List 2017
MP Vyapam Anganvadi Supervisor Admit Card 2017
BOB Specialist Officer Result 2017
TNTET Admit Card 2017
AIBE Admit Card 2017

jalpa prajapati said...

this is a good post..thanks
MU OET Slot Booking 2017

ovy shah said...

Thanks..Sharing with us great information..
JEE Main Result 2017
UPSEE Answer Key 2017
Odisha PST PET Answer Key 2017
UPSSSC Lower Subordinate Services Result 2017
BCCL Junior Overman Admit Card 2017
How to download NEET Admit card on 15th April

eduction exam said...

such a good post sharing us...thank you.
How to download NEET Admit card 2017 on 22nd April
NEET Admit card 2017
HPBOSE 12th Result 2017

eduction exam said...

such a wonderful & interesting post sharing with us..Thanks you.
Ordnance Factory Medak Group C Result 2017
MP Cooperative Bank Clerk Admit Card 2017
KSP KSRP Result 2017
MPPKVVCL JE Result 2017
BET DBT JRF Result 2017
Syndicate Bank SO Answer Key 2017